Monday, April 24, 2006

Smaller is better

"The artillery is getting a new weapon: The Excalibur features a precision-guided warhead as small as 50 pounds, with a near vertical drop to the target.It's about time.

The Army has depended on Air Force CAS for far too long, while the Air Force has steadfastly resisted creating and fielding munitions that are suitable for close-in urban combat."
CounterColumn
And this
Eliot Cohen smacks down retired generals

"Here's Johns Hopkins Professor Eliot Cohen:
One could say much to defend Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld against the recent attacks of half a dozen retired generals--that the indictments are either old ("not enough troops," a trope from April 2003) or vague ("ignoring the Powell doctrine"), plodding ("violating the principles of war," a hazy collection of often-ignored, self-contradictory military platitudes), or downright silly (being disrespectful in meetings, as though generals would never, ever, be caught dressing down subordinates in front of their peers). Generals, one might note, may yield to vanity and pique, institutional parochialism and thwarted ambition, limited introspection and all the other foibles of proud men. One might, finally, observe that in the unhappy generals' account of Iraq there is no alternative strategy proposed, no fellow general held to account by name, scant acceptance of personal responsibility for what went awry on their watch, little repudiation of contrary statements made on active duty.
Read the whole thing. Cohen concludes by castigating Republicans as well as Democrats for exploiting retired flag officers."
CounterColumn

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

On the first, love the unpolitically correct names of the weapon systems: Excalibur and Crusader! Rumsfeld will get grudging credit years after he is gone when we have to field an overwhelming force in days rather than many months. How'd we do that?

On the second, he noted something I thought remarkable, also. Those Generals' writing, reasoning, and rhetorical abilites were far below the standard of many of the enlisted soldiers blogging today. The American Citizen Soldier's effort, written by a E-5 on the subject, was far superior to the Generals' efforts. And he is in the midst of actively fighting the fight!

7:50 AM  
Blogger madtom said...

I'm not sure if you can put the words "Rumsfeld" and "overwhelming force" in the same sentence. But maybe I'm just grumpy this morning

8:56 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home